Originally published as "It necessary to adjust before the State can Grow: The constitution Convention that 1835"

by cutting board E. JeffreyReprinted with permission indigenous the Tar heel Junior Historian. Autumn 1996.Tar heel Junior historian Association, NC Museum that History

See also: State Constitution; Black and also Tan Constitution; Convention of 1835 (from Encyclopedia of phibìc Carolina); Convention of 1868; Convention of 1875; Governor.

*
Reforming the state’s structure was one of the many important and hotly questioned political issues in antebellum phibìc Carolina. The state’s constitution of 1776, i beg your pardon remained mainly unchanged until the convention that 1835, had features that countless North Carolinians had concerned regard together unfair and also undemocratic. The many widely criticized section regarded the an approach of apportioning seats in the basic Assembly.

Before 1835, each county was allowed to elect 2 members come the lower house, well-known as the residence of commons, and also one member to the state senate. Since most the the state’s counties were situated in the eastern component of the state, the east had much more representatives, which allowed it come maintain regulate of both houses of the general Assembly. However by the antebellum period, the western counties had actually grown come cover a bigger area and also were farming faster in population. In fact, by 1830, most North Carolinians lived in the west, and the 1776 device of apportioning representation seemed come them an noticeable violation the the democratic principle of majority rule. In addition, the eastern-controlled legislature repeatedly defeated efforts by westerners to build roads and other transportation enhancements in the west. West citizens believed that economic breakthrough of their ar would not be achieved until the state’s constitution to be amended to offer them a same share of seats in the general Assembly. 

Other troubles with the structure of 1776

North Carolinians native both sections of the state were joined in your dissatisfaction with various other parts of the 1776 constitution. Inhabitants of landscape counties resented the fact that 7 towns (the “boroughs” the Edenton, Halifax, Hillsborough, new Bern, Wilmington, Salisbury, and also Fayetteville) had actually the privilege of electing added members to the home of commons. One more objectionable feature was write-up 32, i beg your pardon prohibited Catholics, Jews, and also members of various other faiths who denied the “being the God or the truth of the good news religion” indigenous holding office.

The 1776 constitution contained numerous components that many thought about undemocratic. Because that example, justices on the ar courts—who offered as the principal officers of local government in phibìc Carolina—were appointed for indefinite state by the basic Assembly fairly than being chosen periodically by neighborhood voters. Likewise, the governor, state judges (such as those top top the supreme court), and also most other state officials were appointed by the legislature, not by well-known vote. Elections for state senators were open up to voters, but those voters had actually to meet particular qualifications, such together owning at least fifty acre of land.

Ironically, the 1776 constitution made no cite of race as a qualification because that voting. As a result, cost-free blacks could and did vote in state elections. That practice displeased countless white voters—particularly in the slaveholding east—who wanted to restrict voting come whites. 

Still, the vast bulk of easterners were willing come tolerate this displeasing facets of the 1776 constitution due to the fact that they go not desire to risk an altering the balance of power in donate of the west. On countless occasions the eastern bulk in the general Assembly defeated convention bills that had actually been introduced by western politicians. Through the 1830s, though, frustrated reformers to be threatening to call a convention there is no the general Assembly’s approval (they can have done the by encouraging regional sheriffs, that were in fee of coordinating poll in antebellum north Carolina, come organize one election). Reformers additionally threatened come secede from north Carolina and set up their very own state. Such threats of revolutionary activity led a couple of prominent easterners prefer William H. Haywood Jr. To join the reform movement in the hope of moderating and also controlling it. 

Finally, the eastern Wants Reforms, also

By the at an early stage 1830s, other determinants were start to affect some easterners to embrace a much more sympathetic perspective toward constitutional reform.

One vital influence to be the development of rail transportation. Leaders in eastern towns like new Bern and Wilmington suddenly started to check out that internal improvements can transform their sleepy communities into growing commercial centers. They started to watch western reformers, who likewise supported transportation improvements, as allies in a crusade because that state-financed railroads quite than as sectional enemies. In 1834, around twenty reform-minded easterners controlled to success election to the general Assembly. In addition, governor David L. Swain, whose popularity extended beyond his indigenous west, threw his influence behind reform and also presented the new legislature v a compelling discussion for hold a convention. A wake up reformer, Haywood was put in charge of illustration up the bill that would certainly authorize a convention.

*
Haywood’s bill called for a special election to be held in April 1835. At the election, voters would certainly be asked to approve a convention and also to selected delegates to the convention. In bespeak to success the required support of Haywood’s fellow easterners, the bill put severe constraints on the convention’s results. That ensured the easterners could control the convention by providing that 2 delegates would certainly be elected from each county. And instead of giving convention delegates the strength to create an entirely new constitution, the convention bill minimal their activities to considering certain amendments come the currently 1776 constitution.

Haywood’s bill noted that delegates come the convention would create a brand-new house the commons that would certainly contain between ninety and also 120 members apportioned follow to “federal population” (defined as cost-free population to add three-fifths that the servant population—the same mechanism used for apportioning the U.S. House of Representatives). North Carolina’s more populous west would obtain a majority of seat to control this reduced house. The bill additionally instructed delegates to produce a new senate that would certainly contain between thirty-four and also fifty members apportioned according to the quantity of taxes payment by their districts into the state treasury. The arrangement allowed the wealthier eastern to keep more seats and also its bulk of regulate in the senate. To represent to the brand-new house and senate would be chosen in respectable 1836. 

On December 31, 1834, Haywood’s bill passed the house of commons by a four-vote margin. Despite the numerous restrictions and also safeguards he had placed in the measure, only a few fellow easterners supported it. 3 days later, the senate approved the invoice by one vote. Together expected, west legislators overwhelmingly sustained the bill. Many of the easterners who finally supported the convention bill were connected with the rail movement.

The distinct election the was organized in April 1835 to choose delegates approved the convention by a vote of 27,550 to 21,694. The vast majority of favorable votes came from the west. 

The Convention Meets for Change

The convention, i m sorry assembled in Raleigh ~ above June 4, 1835, had 130 delegates representing thirty-eight east counties and also twenty-seven western counties. Veteran politician Nathaniel Macon was unanimously preferred as the president.

The an initial amendment to victory approval was elimination the borough representation. Many support for that proposal come from eastern delegates who represented small rural counties the resented the privileges boroughs had held. They likewise wanted to punishment borough to represent for supporting the convention bill.

Eastern delegates were also responsible for beating a proposed amendment to abolish spiritual restrictions on officeholding. The delegates did, however, agree to readjust Article 32 by allowing all “Christians,” rather than just “Protestants,” to hold office. Easterners again listed most of the votes because that an amendment to prohibit complimentary blacks native voting.

As directed, the convention make some significant changes in the structure of state government. The variety of legislators was set at 120 for the residence of commons and fifty for the senate—the maximums allowed by Haywood’s convention bill. Various other amendments moved election the the governor from the general Assembly come voters, expanded the governor’s term native one to two years, and listed that the general Assembly would fulfill biennially (once every two years), instead of every year (every year) as before. 

After granting the whole package that amendments with only twenty negative votes, the convention adjourned on July 11, 1835. As compelled by the convention bill, the brand-new amendments were submitted to voters to it is in ratified. About 90 percent the the votes in favor of the proposed changes were actors by westerners. A comparable percentage the the votes against them were cast by easterners. 

The Most provided Results

Constitutional alters approved in 1835 had vital impact on the citizens of phibìc Carolina. The transforms played a significant role in reducing east-west sectionalism, due to the fact that they offered the west much more power in the general Assembly. Legislation favorable come the expansion of the backcountry and also Mountain region, such together creating brand-new counties and providing state help for inner improvements, can now it is in enacted much more easily. 

Constitutional changes also had a far-ranging influence top top parties and politics. Now that governors had actually to hit for well-known votes statewide, campaigns had to be coordinated. This biennial governors’ campaigns detailed the citizens of north Carolina v a statewide forum because that discussing crucial political issues and hastened the development of a two-party politics system. 

In despite the of the benefits many white north Carolinians obtained as a an outcome of constitution reforms, phibìc Carolina’s government remained one of the least autonomous in the South. Because that example, phibìc Carolina ongoing to be among the few southern says to require voters and also officeholders, favor candidates because that governor and also members the the general Assembly, to own property before they can vote or operation for office. And since representation in the state senate was based upon property ownership and also wealth rather than population, slaveholding counties ongoing to have a disproportionate influence over legislation. Moreover, constitutional reform was in reality a action backward for complimentary African American phibìc Carolinians: They lost the best to vote altogether. *At the time this post was written, thomas E. Jeffrey was the combine director of the thomas A.


You are watching: What was the effect of property qualifications on voters and candidates in the new states?


See more: The Two Basic Families Of Structural Systems In Architecture Are:

Edison Papers, a project sponsored by Rutgers, the State university of brand-new Jersey, and also the national Park Service.