By:Stephen C. Wagner(Department of Biology, Stephen F. Austin State University)©2010stillproud.org Education

*

*

*

*

A keystone in an arch"s crown secures the various other stones in place. Keystone varieties play the same duty in countless ecological areas by keeping the structure and integrity that the community.

You are watching: Which of the following are most likely to be keystone species in an ecosystem?


The term keystone varieties was very first coined by Robert Paine (1966) after comprehensive studies evaluating the interaction strengths that food network in rocky intertidal ecosystems in the Pacific Northwest. One of his research sites, located at Mukkaw Bay, contained a neighborhood consistently dominated by the same species of mussels, barnacles, and the starfish, Pisaster ochraceus, i beg your pardon preys ~ above the other types as a height predator (Figure 1).

Paine (1966) had observed the the diversity of organisms in rocky intertidal ecosystems declined as the number of predators in those ecosystems decreased. The hypothesized that few of these consumers can be playing a greater role than rather in regulating the numbers of types coexisting in this communities. He tested his theory in an experiment that involved selecting a "typical" piece of coast at Mukkaw Bay, around 8 meters lengthy by 2 meter wide, the was kept complimentary of starfish. This area was contrasted to one adjacent, undisturbed manage area of equal size.


Paine it was observed dramatic alters in the temperate intertidal ecosystem after Pisaster was artificially removed compared with the manage area that stayed unchanged in its varieties number and distribution. The intertidal area where Pisaster had been gotten rid of was defined by countless changes. Continuing to be members that the ecosystem"s food web automatically began to compete with each other to occupy restricted space and resources. Within 3 months that the Pisaster removal, the barnacle, Balanus glandula, occupied 60 to 80% the the available space within the research area. Ripe months later, Blanus glandula had actually been replaced by rapidly cultivation populations of another barnacle Mitella and also the mussel Mytilus. This phenomenon ongoing until fewer and fewer species occupied the area and also it was conquered by Mytilus and also a couple of adult Mitella species. At some point the sequence of types wiped out populaces of benthic algae. This led to some species, such as the limpet, come emigrate indigenous the ecosystem due to the fact that of lack of food and/or space. In ~ a year that the starfish"s removal, types diversity substantially decreased in the examine area native fifteen come eight varieties (Figure 2).


In his seminal document that complied with this work, Paine (1969) acquired the hatchet keystone types to explain the starfish in this intertidal ecosystems. That these types he commented: "The types composition and physical appearance were significantly modified by the activities of a solitary native species high in the food web. These individual populaces are the keystone the the community"s structure, and the truth of the community and its unaltered persistence with time."

Paine walk on to explain the criteria because that a keystone species. A keystone types exerts top-down affect on reduced trophic levels and also prevents types at lower trophic levels from monopolizing vital resources, such as competition for room or an essential producer food sources. This paper represented a watershed in the description of environmental relationships in between species. In the twenty years that complied with its publication, it was cited in end ninety publications. Additionally, the original document describing the intertidal areas was quote in end 850 records during the very same time period (Mills et al. 1993).


There room a number of other well-described examples where keystone types act together determinate predators. Sea otters (i) regulate sea urchin populations, which in turn feed top top kelp and other macroalgae (Duggins 1980). The otters keep the sea urchin populations in check, thus enabling enough kelp forests to stay as a habitat because that a selection of other species. Together a result, the whole ecosystem is maintained in balance. In terrestrial environments, fire ants function as keystone predators by suppressing the number of individuals and species of arthropods that might be harmful come agriculture.

Keystone species also play necessary roles in numerous other ecosystems (Mills et al. 1993). Because that example, hummingbirds are occasionally referred to as keystone mutualists since they affect the persistence of numerous plant species through pollination. Top top the other hand, keystone modifiers, such as the phibìc American beaver (Casor candensis), recognize the pervasiveness and tasks of countless other types by dramatically altering the setting (Figure 3). Species like the Saguaro cactus (Carnegiea gigantea) in desert environments and also palm and fig tree in tropical woodlands are referred to as keystone hosts because they provide habitat for a variety of various other species. Keystone prey are species that deserve to maintain your numbers in spite of being preyed upon, therefore controlling the density of a predator.


Figure 3:A dam constructed by beavers together keystone modifiers
© 2010 stillproud.org education and learning All civil liberties reserved.

Gray Wolves: A case Study of Keystone species Removal and also Restoration


Gray wolves (Canis lupus, number 4) once roamed the western parts of phibìc America from Alaska come Mexico. Throughout the latter component of the nineteenth century, most of the vital prey because that wolves — bison, deer, elk, and also moose — to be severely depleted by person settlers. The wolf soon became the opponents of the ranchers and farmers once they turned to preying upon sheep and other livestock (Grooms 1993, Breck & Meier 2004, Outland 2010).


Canis lupus), a keystone species in Yellowstone nationwide Park" />
Figure 4:The gray wolf (Canis lupus), a keystone species in Yellowstone nationwide Park
© 2010 stillproud.org education and learning All legal rights reserved.

When the commonwealth government collection aside the higher Yellowstone Ecosystem (GYE) as a national park in 1872, around three to four hundred wolves to be present, preying greatly upon big hooved ungulates such as elk (Cervus canadensis, number 5) and bison (Yellowstone association 1996). Fearing the wolves" influence on elk and bison herds and livestock own by area ranchers, the federal government began eradicating the wolf population. Bounty programs that continued until 1965 readily available as lot as $50 every wolf. Wolves were trapped, shot, dug from their dens, pursued with dogs, and poisoned. In Yellowstone nationwide Park, park rangers killed the critical two remaining pups in 1924. Through the 1930s wolves had actually been efficiently eliminated native the contiguous 48 States and Mexico and only continued to be in high numbers in Alaska.


Cervus canadensis), major prey the gray wolf (Canis lupus)" />
Figure 5:The elk (Cervus canadensis), major prey the gray wolves (Canis lupus)
© 2010 stillproud.org education and learning All legal rights reserved.

With their major predator eliminated, elk populaces exploded, leading to the overgrazing the plants, particularly those found in riparian zones (Laliberte & Ripple 2004). Far-reaching declines in the populaces of countless plant species (e.g., aspen, willow) resulted, which consequently influenced other wildlife, such together beaver and songbird populations (Ripple & Breschetta 2004, Hallofsky & Ripple 2008). Intensive browsing of aspen (Populus tremuloides) stands, because that example, led to a rapid decrease in the variety of seedlings and root sprouts cultivation into saplings and also trees. For countless stands of this trees, only huge diameter trees (i.e., those that had matured before the wolves were eradicated) remained.

Disappearance of these and other plant types not only brought about the loss of habitat for many other animals but additionally influenced various other ecological factors (Smith et al. 2009), consisting of stream financial institution stability, the deposition of necessary matter and fine sediment in riparian zones, water temperature regulation via shading, and nutrient cycling. The removed of wolves for this reason led to the instability of riparian and also other environmentally perceptible areas.


After the United claims Congress pass the original Endangered types Preservation act in 1966, the gray wolf made the initial Endangered varieties List. The succeeding Endangered species Act the 1973 called for your restoration. Consequently, the nationwide Park Service readjusted their policy to reclaim natural problems within Yellowstone national Park, consisting of the reintroduction that the gray wolf (Smith & Bangs 2009). In 1995, the federal government began reintroducing gray wolves into the GYE. Initially, fourteen wolf were caught in Canada and also relocated come one-acre acclimation pens whereby they were organized for ten weeks prior to being released into the GYE. This procedure was repetitive in 1996 and also 1997 with an additional seventeen wolf from Canada and ten pups from Montana (Smith et al. 2009). Because that the many part, wolf populations have ongoing to prosper at a quick rate, averaging 17% every year (Smith & Bangs 2009). At the end of 2009, over there were between 96 and 98 wolf in Yellowstone, v 14 packs, 1 non-pack grouping, and 2 loners (Figure 6). Park staff taped 365 prey pets killed by wolves, most of which were elk (302).

Despite part setbacks (e.g., disease outbreaks in ~ the fledgling wolf packs), recovery efforts in the GYE have considerably surpassed expectations. Since their reintroduction, wolves have overwhelmingly target elk over other prey. This has coincided with an increase in willow heights in several areas. This may show that a wolf-elk-willow trophic cascade has been reestablished in ~ the GYE. Furthermore, investigators believe that repair of willow populations has actually led to a ten-fold rise in beaver populaces (Smith 2004) and also a far-ranging songbird rebound (Baril & Hansen 2007).

Halofsky & Ripple (2008) uncovered that aspen browsing by elk had ceased in locations burned throughout the historical 1988 fires yet continued in unburned areas. These outcomes were attributed to the enhanced risk of wolf predation in burned areas. The writer proposed the a recoupling the fire with enhanced predation hazard from wolf may help improve aspen restoration. The results additionally suggest that much an ext research requirements to be carried out to determine the effects of wolf reintroduction into the GYE.


The ide of keystone varieties was very first proposed and demonstrated in the 1960s by the prominence of top-predator starfish in intertidal ecosystems. Keystone species are types that pat a disproportionately big role in the prevalence and populace levels that other species within your ecosystem or community. The restore of the gray wolf after its eradication native Yellowstone national Park, practically ninety year ago, demonstrates how critical keystone varieties are to the irreversible sustainability the the ecosystems lock inhabit. Most importantly, the preservation and also restoration that keystone types is vital for preserving and/or reestablishing the historical structure and duty of the ecosystems they inhabit.


Baril, L. &Hansen, A. Avian solution to willow height development in Yellowstone"sNorthern range. Report to Yellowstone nationwide Park, 2007.

Beck, S. &Meier, T. Regulating wolf depredation in the united States: past, present, andfuture. Sheep and Goat research study Journal19, 41–46 (2004).

Duggins, D. O.Kelp beds and sea otters: an experimental approach. Ecology 61, 447–453 (1980).

Grooms, S. Return of the Wolf. Minocqua, WI:Northword Press, 1993.

Halofsky, J.& Ripple, W. Recoupling fire and aspen recruitment ~ wolfreintroduction in Yellowstone national Park. Woodland Ecology and Management 256, 1004–1008 (2008).

Laliberte, A. S.& Ripple, W. J. Range contractions of phibìc American carnivores andungulates. BioScience 54, 123–138 (2004).

Mills, L. S. Et al. The keystone-species ide in ecology and conservation. BioScience 43, 219–224 (1993).

Outland, K. Who"safraid of the big bad wolf? The Yellowstonewolves controversy. Newspaper of YoungInvestigators 11, (2010).

Paine, R. T. Foodweb complexity and varieties diversity. AmericanNaturalist 100, 65–75 (1966).

Paine, R. T. Anote on trophic complexity and community stability. American Naturalist 103,91–93 (1961).

Yellowstone Association. The YellowstoneWolf: A Guide and also Sourcebook. Edited by P. Shullery. Winnipeg: Red river Books,1996.

Ripple, W. J.& Breschetta, R. L. Wolves, elk, willows, and trophic cascades in the upperGallatin range in Southwester Montana, USA. Woodland Ecology and also Management 200,161–181 (2004).

See more: Rose Colored Glass Johnson Crossword Clue, Rose Colored Glass Singer Johnson Crossword Clue

Smith, D. W. 2003Beaver Survey. Interior Memorandum. Yellowstone nationwide Park, 2004.

Smith, D. W. & Bangs, E. E. "Reintroduction ofwolves to Yellowstone nationwide Park: history, values and ecosystems." In Reintroduction the Top-Order Predators,eds. M. W. Hayward & M. J. Somers (Oxford, UK:Wiley-Blackwell, 2009), 92–125.

Smith, D. W. Et al. "Wolf recolonization that theMadison Headwaters Area in Yellowstone." In TheEcology of huge Mammals in central Yellowstone, eds. R. A. Garrott et al. (New York, NY: AcademicPress, 2009), 283–304